/ Compare · OAKMONT vs overlay widgets
A script cannot fixwhat the source gets wrong.
Accessibility overlays inject a widget and promise instant compliance. Audits, regulators and assistive technology all read the page itself. OAKMONT fixes the source, verifies the result with deterministic checks on the rendered page, and signs evidence anyone can verify.
Side by side
| Dimension | An overlay widget | OAKMONT |
|---|---|---|
| What changes on your site | A script tag. The widget repaints the page for visitors who open its panel; your markup, templates and components stay exactly as they were. | The source. We fix markup, semantics, contrast, alt text and keyboard order in the code itself, so every visitor and every assistive technology gets the corrected page. |
| WCAG conformance | Out of a script's reach. Conformance is a property of the page as delivered, and an audit tests the DOM a screen reader receives, which still carries the original defects. | Deliverables are checked against WCAG 2.1 AA with deterministic checks on the live rendered page, the same surface an auditor tests. |
| EAA and legal standing | No published EU guidance treats a widget as a route to conformance, and lawsuits against sites running overlays are widely reported in the US. The banner can draw attention rather than deflect it. | Source-level fixes plus a measured, dated record of conformance, which is what EN 301 549 assessments and market surveillance bodies actually look at. |
| Evidence produced | A badge and a vendor certificate that no third party can check independently. | Signed attestations anyone can verify on a public page, scan reports with severities, and an evidence pack you can hand to a regulator, a lawyer or a procurement team. |
| PDFs and documents | Untouched. A page script cannot repair a PDF invoice, a form or a downloadable report. | Document remediation is part of the service: tagged, checked PDFs, plus a free PDF checker you can run yourself. |
| Performance cost | One more third-party script on every page load, for every visitor, forever. | Zero runtime addition. Fixed source ships as ordinary HTML; there is nothing extra to load. |
| Lock-in | Remove the script and you are exactly where you started. The subscription bought a rental, not a repair. | Fixes live in your codebase and stay yours if you leave. Monitoring is optional and cancellable. |
| Price shape | A subscription that never ends and never reduces the underlying work. | Fixed prices per fix, published up front, plus an optional monitor whose job is to keep an already-fixed site fixed. |
What changes on your site
- An overlay widget
- A script tag. The widget repaints the page for visitors who open its panel; your markup, templates and components stay exactly as they were.
- OAKMONT
- The source. We fix markup, semantics, contrast, alt text and keyboard order in the code itself, so every visitor and every assistive technology gets the corrected page.
WCAG conformance
- An overlay widget
- Out of a script's reach. Conformance is a property of the page as delivered, and an audit tests the DOM a screen reader receives, which still carries the original defects.
- OAKMONT
- Deliverables are checked against WCAG 2.1 AA with deterministic checks on the live rendered page, the same surface an auditor tests.
EAA and legal standing
- An overlay widget
- No published EU guidance treats a widget as a route to conformance, and lawsuits against sites running overlays are widely reported in the US. The banner can draw attention rather than deflect it.
- OAKMONT
- Source-level fixes plus a measured, dated record of conformance, which is what EN 301 549 assessments and market surveillance bodies actually look at.
Evidence produced
- An overlay widget
- A badge and a vendor certificate that no third party can check independently.
- OAKMONT
- Signed attestations anyone can verify on a public page, scan reports with severities, and an evidence pack you can hand to a regulator, a lawyer or a procurement team.
PDFs and documents
- An overlay widget
- Untouched. A page script cannot repair a PDF invoice, a form or a downloadable report.
- OAKMONT
- Document remediation is part of the service: tagged, checked PDFs, plus a free PDF checker you can run yourself.
Performance cost
- An overlay widget
- One more third-party script on every page load, for every visitor, forever.
- OAKMONT
- Zero runtime addition. Fixed source ships as ordinary HTML; there is nothing extra to load.
Lock-in
- An overlay widget
- Remove the script and you are exactly where you started. The subscription bought a rental, not a repair.
- OAKMONT
- Fixes live in your codebase and stay yours if you leave. Monitoring is optional and cancellable.
Price shape
- An overlay widget
- A subscription that never ends and never reduces the underlying work.
- OAKMONT
- Fixed prices per fix, published up front, plus an optional monitor whose job is to keep an already-fixed site fixed.
/ The difference
The difference: verified at the source
An overlay asks you to trust a banner. Our position is that compliance is a property of the page, so we change the page and then prove it, with checks a machine runs the same way every time and evidence a stranger can verify.
- Deterministic checks
- Every deliverable passes automated accessibility checks before a person signs off. Pass or fail, not a marketing claim.
- Rendered measurement
- Scans run against the live rendered page, the DOM assistive technology actually receives, not a guess from raw HTML.
- Signed proof
- Attestations are cryptographically signed and verifiable on a public page by anyone you show them to.
- Published evidence
- Scores, statements and monitoring history can be published and shared, so a claim of conformance has a record behind it.
Honest questions
- Do overlay widgets make a site WCAG conformant?
- No. WCAG conformance is a property of the page as delivered, and an audit tests the markup and behaviour that assistive technology receives. A widget can adjust presentation for users who open its panel, but the underlying defects - missing semantics, broken keyboard order, untagged documents - are still there when the page is tested.
- Are overlays a legal risk?
- We do not give legal advice, but the pattern is widely reported: in the United States a substantial share of digital accessibility lawsuits each year are filed against sites that run an overlay, and we know of no EU guidance that accepts a widget as a route to EAA conformance. An overlay does not remove the duty to make the service itself accessible.
- We already pay for an overlay. Can we still use OAKMONT?
- Yes, and you do not have to remove it first. Start with a free scan; it measures the rendered page as delivered. If the results are good, keep whatever you like. If they are not, we fix the source, and you can then decide whether the widget still earns its subscription.
- A widget costs a few hundred a year. Why pay more to fix the source?
- Because the two products are different. The widget is a recurring fee for a script that leaves the defects in place. A fix is a repair that stays in your codebase, with signed evidence you can show a regulator or a buyer. Over a few years the overlay usually costs more and settles nothing.
Measure the page,not the banner.
A free scan of your rendered page shows what an audit would find, overlay or not.
