- Level
- A
- Since
- WCAG 2.0
1.2.1 Audio-only and Video-only (Prerecorded)
A recording with only sound needs a text version, and a recording with only pictures needs a text description or an audio track that carries the same information.
/ What it requires
A recording with only sound, such as a podcast or a recorded statement, needs a text version that carries the same information. A recording with only pictures, such as a silent animation or a screen recording without narration, needs either a text description or an audio track that tells the same story. The point is that someone who cannot hear the audio, or cannot see the video, gets everything it contains. That covers people who are deaf or hard of hearing, people who are blind or have low vision, and people who are deafblind and read the text in braille.
The criterion applies only to prerecorded media that is audio alone or video alone, with no interaction. Video with sound is handled by 1.2.2, 1.2.3 and 1.2.5. There is one exception: a recording that only repeats text already on the page, and is clearly labelled as an alternative to that text, needs nothing more. An audio track written as the equivalent of a silent video does not need its own transcript either.
/ How pages fail it
- A podcast episode page offers an audio player and three lines of show notes, and no transcript anywhere.
- A silent screen recording walks through setting up an account, and nothing on the page describes those steps in words.
- The alternative offered for an audio clip is a file name such as ep42_final.mp3, or placeholder text such as "Transcript coming soon".
- The transcript of a recorded interview drops the speaker names and the questions from the audience, so it no longer holds what the recording does.
- An animated product tour with no sound shows six features, and the text beside it describes only the first one.
/ How to check it yourself
- List every recording on the page: audio players, embedded podcast widgets, silent videos and animations that carry information, and media files offered for download.
- Sort them. Audio alone and video alone belong here. Video with sound is checked under 1.2.2, 1.2.3 and 1.2.5.
- For audio alone, find a transcript on the page or linked right next to the player. Play the recording and follow along to confirm nothing said and no important sound is missing.
- For video alone, watch it, then read the text description or listen to the audio track. Every action and every piece of on-screen text that matters should be there, in the same order.
- Where a recording only repeats text on the page, check that a label next to it says so.
/ How to fix it
- Publish a full transcript as HTML on the same page, or link it immediately after the player with link text such as "Transcript of episode 42".
- Name each speaker in the transcript and note sounds that carry meaning, such as [laughter] or [phone rings].
- For a silent video, write a description of what happens in the order it happens, or record an audio track that narrates it.
- Do not ship an empty or placeholder alternative. Put the recording live together with its text, not ahead of it.
- When a recording only repeats text on the page, say so beside it, for example "Video version of the steps above".
/ What our scanner checks
No automated check in our scan is filed under 1.2.1. The scan reads the page, not the media files it links to, so it cannot tell a podcast with a full transcript from one without, or a silent animation that is described from one that is not. Someone has to play each recording and compare it with the text beside it, and that is done in a manual audit.
/ Who fails it, in our own measurements
The weekly index has no figures for this criterion, because none of the checks the site scan runs can test it. A person judges it, which is what a manual audit is for.
One page per body, measured by automated checks on a weekly schedule. Any body that has fixed something since the last sweep will show it at the next one, and every entity page carries a right of reply.
/ Questions about this criterion
Does a podcast need a transcript under WCAG?
Yes. Success criterion 1.2.1 at level A asks for a text alternative that presents the same information as any prerecorded audio-only content, and for a podcast that means a transcript. Captions are not the tool here, because there is no picture to synchronise with. The only exception is audio that repeats text already on the page and is clearly labelled as such.
Does a silent video need audio description?
Not necessarily. For prerecorded video with no sound, 1.2.1 lets the author choose between a text alternative and an audio track, as long as either one presents the same information as the video. A written description of the steps on screen meets it. If you choose an audio track instead, that track does not need a transcript of its own.
Does 1.2.1 cover live audio, such as an internet radio stream?
No. 1.2.1 covers prerecorded media only. Live audio-only content is covered by 1.2.9 Audio-only (Live), which is level AAA, so it is not part of a level AA requirement. A recording of the stream published afterwards is prerecorded, and 1.2.1 applies to it.
