Level
AA
Since
WCAG 2.0
/ WCAG criterion

1.2.4 Captions (Live)

Video with sound broadcast live needs captions while it is happening.

/ What it requires

When a site broadcasts video with sound live, such as a webcast, an online event or a live product launch, the sound needs captions while it is happening. Live means captured from a real event and sent to the viewer with no more than a short broadcast delay. The captions must carry what is said and the sounds needed to follow it, and identify who is speaking. They are what lets people who are deaf or hard of hearing follow a broadcast at the same time as everyone else.

W3C says the criterion was meant for broadcasts. It does not require that two-way video calls between people in a web application are captioned; that responsibility lies with the people making the call. Captions may come from a real-time captioning service. Live audio with no video, such as an internet radio stream, is not covered here but by 1.2.9 at level AAA. A recording of the broadcast published later is prerecorded and falls under 1.2.2.

/ How pages fail it

  • A company streams its annual results webcast on its investor pages with no captions.
  • A live event relies on automatic captions that nobody watches, and they garble the names of speakers and every figure quoted.
  • The main talk of a webinar is captioned, and the question round that follows, when the audience speaks, is not.
  • On a panel stream the captions show the words but never say who is speaking when the microphone moves to another panellist.
  • A live stream has a caption track, but the custom player on the site has no captions control, so the captions never appear.

/ How to check it yourself

  1. Find every live stream on the site: webcasts, event pages, live shopping and embedded live players. Note when the next broadcast is.
  2. Join a broadcast while it is live, not the replay afterwards.
  3. Turn captions on in the player and confirm that they appear, keep pace with speech and run through the whole broadcast, including the questions at the end.
  4. Watch for speaker changes and important sounds, and check that the captions note them.
  5. Check the published recording separately against 1.2.2, because a replay is prerecorded content.

/ How to fix it

  • Book a human real-time captioner or a live captioning service for each broadcast and send its output to the player as closed or open captions.
  • If the captions come from speech recognition, feed the service a list of names and product terms where it accepts one, and have a person watch the output during the broadcast.
  • Use a streaming platform and a player that carry a live caption track and show a captions control to the viewer.
  • Ask the captioner to mark a new speaker by name each time the voice changes.
  • Replace the live captions with a corrected caption file before the recording is published as a replay.

/ What our scanner checks

Our scan has no check for 1.2.4. A live stream exists only while it is broadcast, so a scan of the page at any other moment sees an idle player or a recording. Live captions are checked by joining a broadcast, which belongs in a manual audit planned around the streaming schedule.

/ Who fails it, in our own measurements

The weekly index has no figures for this criterion, because none of the checks the site scan runs can test it. A person judges it, which is what a manual audit is for.

One page per body, measured by automated checks on a weekly schedule. Any body that has fixed something since the last sweep will show it at the next one, and every entity page carries a right of reply.

/ Questions about this criterion

Do video calls need live captions under WCAG?

Not under 1.2.4. W3C states the criterion was intended for broadcast of synchronised media and does not require that two-way calls between individuals in a web application are captioned regardless of the users' needs. Responsibility for captions in a call lies with the callers or the host, not with the application. A live webcast to an audience is covered.

Are automatic live captions enough for 1.2.4?

Only if what they produce meets the definition of captions: the speech and the sound information needed to understand the broadcast. W3C notes that live captions can come from a real-time captioning service. Automatic output that garbles names and figures, or drops passages, does not carry the content, and the broadcast fails even though a captions button exists.

Does a live audio-only stream need captions?

Not under 1.2.4, which covers live audio inside synchronised media, meaning sound that goes with video. Live audio with no video is covered by 1.2.9 Audio-only (Live), which asks for a text alternative and is level AAA. A site that conforms at level AA does not have to meet it.