Level
A
Since
WCAG 2.0
Entries
182 / 193
/ WCAG criterion

1.3.1 Info and Relationships

Structure that is visible on screen (headings, lists, tables, labels) has to exist in the markup, not only in the styling.

/ What it requires

What a sighted visitor understands from layout has to be available to software too. Bold large text reads as a heading, an indented column reads as a list, a grid reads as a table, and a word beside a box reads as its label. Unless the markup says the same thing, a screen reader announces a flat stream of text, and its user cannot jump between headings, hear which column a cell belongs to, or learn what a form field is asking for.

The criterion is met when each such relationship can be determined from the code or is stated in text. A required field marked with the word required passes; one marked only with a red border does not. WCAG does not prescribe one h1 per page or forbid a skipped heading level, and it names no exceptions here. The failure is the mismatch: structure that exists for the eye and not in the markup, or markup that claims a structure the content does not have.

/ How pages fail it

  • Headings are paragraphs or div elements styled large and bold, so the page has no outline to navigate.
  • A form field has no label element or accessible name, or relies on a placeholder that vanishes on typing.
  • A data table has no th cells, so each value is announced without its column or row.
  • A list is built from line breaks and dashes, or a ul contains children that are not li elements.
  • A group of radio buttons or checkboxes has no fieldset and legend, so each option is announced without the question.

/ How to check it yourself

  1. List the headings in a screen reader (NVDA: Insert+F7) or with a browser extension that shows the page outline. Compare the list with what looks like a heading on screen.
  2. Click the visible label of each form field. If the cursor does not land in the field, the label is not associated with it.
  3. Inspect each data table for th elements and the scope attribute, and each visual list for ul, ol and li.
  4. Turn styles off (Firefox: View, Page Style, No Style) and check that headings, lists and tables are still recognisable.
  5. With a screen reader, jump from landmark to landmark and confirm that the main content, the navigation and the footer can each be reached.

/ How to fix it

  • Mark headings with h1 to h6 in an order that follows the content, and do not use heading elements only to make text bigger.
  • Give every input, select and textarea a label element tied to it with for and id, and wrap related options in a fieldset with a legend.
  • Write header cells as th with scope="col" or scope="row", and add a caption that names the table.
  • Build lists with ul, ol and li, with li as the only direct children.
  • Wrap the regions of the page in main, nav, header and footer, and connect each tab to its panel with aria-controls.

/ What our scanner checks

The static pass flags a missing or repeated h1, jumps in heading level, a missing main element and tables without th. The rendered pass adds content outside every landmark, lists with stray children, fields with no label or only a placeholder, option groups without a legend and tabs not linked to a panel. HTML_CodeSniffer adds empty headings. Text that only looks like a heading is invisible to all of them.

/ Who fails it, in our own measurements

Measured bodies failing this criterion, most instances first
BodySectorInstancesScore
Bremencity · DE295
Państwowa Inspekcja Pracygovernment · PL2110
State of Washingtongovernment · US178
Bundesratgovernment · DE1614
Gdyniacity · PL157
Bydgoszczcity · PL137
State of Floridagovernment · US128
Amtraktransport · US111
Seattlecity · US1012
Denvercity · US939
Poznańcity · PL91
Bundeszentrale für politische Bildunggovernment · DE810
Düsseldorfcity · DE89
Statistisches Bundesamtgovernment · DE89
Las Vegascity · US78
Rzecznik Praw Obywatelskichgovernment · PL742
Harris Countygovernment · US619
Indianapoliscity · US618
Karlsruher Institut für Technologieeducation · DE619
Ohio State Universityeducation · US66
Politechnika Warszawskaeducation · PL612
Uniwersytet Jagiellońskieducation · PL61
Urząd Ochrony Danych Osobowychgovernment · PL66
Wrocławcity · PL62
Łódźcity · PL63
Chicago Transit Authoritytransport · US54
Deutsche Rentenversicherunggovernment · DE55
Los Angeles Countygovernment · US510
State of Pennsylvaniagovernment · US521
Uniwersytet Wrocławskieducation · PL513
Bundesministerium der Justizgovernment · DE47
Deutsche Nationalbibliothekculture · DE423
HealthCare.govhealth · US457
Humboldt-Universität zu Berlineducation · DE435
Katowicecity · PL412
Leipzigcity · DE422
Library of Congressculture · US430
Medicarehealth · US451
Nürnbergcity · DE45
Poczta Polskagovernment · PL416
Prezydent RPgovernment · PL412
RWTH Aacheneducation · DE418
Robert Koch-Instituthealth · DE410
Sejm RPgovernment · PL49
Szkoła Główna Handlowaeducation · PL412
Universität Heidelbergeducation · DE421
Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny w Krakowieeducation · PL415
Uniwersytet Łódzkieducation · PL49
Uniwersytet Śląskieducation · PL48
Austincity · US313
Białystokcity · PL337
Biblioteka Narodowaculture · PL317
Bundesagentur für Arbeitgovernment · DE316
Bundesministerium der Finanzengovernment · DE313
Bundesministerium des Innerngovernment · DE310
Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschunggovernment · DE38
Bundesministerium für Gesundheitgovernment · DE346
Bundestaggovernment · DE310
Bundesverfassungsgerichtgovernment · DE318
Gliwicecity · PL313
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität Müncheneducation · DE312
Ministerstwo Klimatu i Środowiskagovernment · PL334
Najwyższa Izba Kontroligovernment · PL341
Narodowy Instytut Dziedzictwaculture · PL36
Państwowa Komisja Wyborczagovernment · PL315
Państwowa Straż Pożarnagovernment · PL328
Phoenixcity · US31
Politechnika Łódzkaeducation · PL35
Politechnika Śląskaeducation · PL32
Płockcity · PL352
Rzeszówcity · PL38
San Franciscocity · US328
State of Texasgovernment · US322
Travis Countygovernment · US337
Trybunał Konstytucyjnygovernment · PL314
University of Texas at Austineducation · US321
Uniwersytet Warszawskieducation · PL33
Zakład Ubezpieczeń Społecznychgovernment · PL327
Berlincity · DE241
Bundesnetzagenturgovernment · DE29
Bundesregierunggovernment · DE24
Centrum e-Zdrowiahealth · PL260
Częstochowacity · PL221
Dallascity · US223
Detroitcity · US240
Dresdencity · DE215
Generalna Dyrekcja Dróg Krajowych i Autostradtransport · PL234
Gorzów Wielkopolskicity · PL26
Kancelaria Prezesa Rady Ministrówgovernment · PL236
Kasa Rolniczego Ubezpieczenia Społecznegogovernment · PL236
Komisja Nadzoru Finansowegogovernment · PL28
Krakówcity · PL212
Lublincity · PL217
Miami-Dade Countygovernment · US220
Ministerstwo Cyfryzacjigovernment · PL237
Ministerstwo Edukacjigovernment · PL247
Ministerstwo Finansówgovernment · PL247
Ministerstwo Infrastrukturygovernment · PL238
Ministerstwo Kulturygovernment · PL247
Ministerstwo Nauki i Szkolnictwa Wyższegogovernment · PL247
Ministerstwo Rodziny i Polityki Społecznejgovernment · PL237
Ministerstwo Rolnictwagovernment · PL232
Ministerstwo Rozwoju i Technologiigovernment · PL236
Ministerstwo Spraw Wewnętrznychgovernment · PL237
Ministerstwo Spraw Zagranicznychgovernment · PL238
Ministerstwo Sprawiedliwościgovernment · PL225
Ministerstwo Zdrowiagovernment · PL247
Minneapoliscity · US279
Narodowy Bank Polskigovernment · PL223
Narodowy Fundusz Zdrowiahealth · PL218
New York Public Libraryculture · US224
Olsztyncity · PL28
Opolecity · PL28
PKP SAtransport · PL272
Pacjent.gov.plhealth · PL29
Philadelphiacity · US28
Polski Instytut Sztuki Filmowejculture · PL27
Senat RPgovernment · PL224
Stiftung Preußischer Kulturbesitzculture · DE221
Sąd Najwyższygovernment · PL214
Technische Universität Müncheneducation · DE212
Tychycity · PL220
University of California, Berkeleyeducation · US271
Universität Hamburgeducation · DE237
Uniwersytet Gdańskieducation · PL218
Urząd Zamówień Publicznychgovernment · PL247
Zamek Królewski w Warszawieculture · PL216
AGHeducation · PL154
Baltimorecity · US17
Bostoncity · US16
Centers for Disease Controlhealth · US18
Department of Educationgovernment · US175
Department of Justicegovernment · US127
Department of Laborgovernment · US146
Deutsche Bahntransport · DE16
Elblągcity · PL120
Federal Aviation Administrationtransport · US114
Frankfurt am Maincity · DE140
Freie Universität Berlineducation · DE17
Gdańskcity · PL12
Główny Urząd Statystycznygovernment · PL116
Hannovercity · DE110
Houstoncity · US17
Instytut Pamięci Narodowejgovernment · PL143
Internal Revenue Servicegovernment · US120
Kielcecity · PL171
King Countygovernment · US113
Krajowa Administracja Skarbowagovernment · PL15
Kölncity · DE116
LA Metrotransport · US117
Münchencity · DE122
NASAgovernment · US120
Narodowy Instytut Zdrowia Publicznegohealth · PL125
Nashvillecity · US114
National Institutes of Healthhealth · US171
National Weather Servicegovernment · US134
New Orleanscity · US17
New York Citycity · US137
PKP Intercitytransport · PL12
Policjagovernment · PL112
Politechnika Gdańskaeducation · PL122
Politechnika Poznańskaeducation · PL14
Politechnika Wrocławskaeducation · PL117
Radomcity · PL12
Rybnikcity · PL17
Smithsonianculture · US114
Social Security Administrationgovernment · US1-
Sosnowieccity · PL128
State of Californiagovernment · US172
State of Georgiagovernment · US156
Stuttgartcity · DE16
Szczecincity · PL13
Teatr Wielki Opera Narodowaculture · PL13
Toruńcity · PL111
University of Floridaeducation · US123
Uniwersytet Marii Curie-Skłodowskiejeducation · PL19
Uniwersytet Mikołaja Kopernikaeducation · PL17
Urząd Komunikacji Elektronicznejgovernment · PL125
Warszawacity · PL120
Warszawski Uniwersytet Medycznyeducation · PL113
Zarząd Transportu Miejskiego Warszawatransport · PL177
Zielona Góracity · PL17

One page per body, measured by automated checks on a weekly schedule. Any body that has fixed something since the last sweep will show it at the next one, and every entity page carries a right of reply.

/ Questions about this criterion

Is skipping a heading level a WCAG failure?

Not by itself. 1.3.1 asks that the heading structure in the markup reflects the structure of the content; it does not say that h2 must be followed by h3. It is still worth fixing, because screen reader users skim a page by its outline and a gap reads like a missing section. That is why our scanner reports it as a moderate finding.

Can a page have more than one h1?

WCAG does not forbid it. It is enough that headings are marked up as headings and their levels match how the content is organised. One h1 naming the page is the convention most screen reader users expect, so several make the outline harder to read. Our scanner lists more than one h1 as a moderate finding under 1.3.1: a sign of weak structure, not proof of a failure.

Is a placeholder enough to label a form field?

No. A placeholder disappears as soon as somebody types, is often too pale to read, and is not treated as a label by every assistive technology. Use a visible label element connected to the field with for and id. Where a visible label is not possible, such as a single search box with a button, aria-label gives the field a name.

Is WCAG 1.3.1 level A or AA?

Level A, the lowest level, so every claim of AA conformance includes it. It has been part of WCAG since version 2.0 and is in 2.1 and 2.2 under the same number.

Does WCAG 1.3.1 apply under the European Accessibility Act?

Yes, through EN 301 549, the standard used to show conformity with the EAA's requirements for websites and apps. Clause 9.1.3.1 requires a web page to satisfy WCAG 2.1 success criterion 1.3.1, clause 10.1.3.1 applies it to documents such as PDFs, and clause 11.1.3.1 to software.