Level
A
Since
WCAG 2.0
/ WCAG criterion

1.3.3 Sensory Characteristics

An instruction must not identify things only by shape, colour, size, position or sound, such as "the round button" or "the menu on the right".

/ What it requires

Instructions have to work for someone who cannot see the screen or hear the page. "Press the round button", "use the menu on the right" or "continue when you hear the tone" point to things by shape, colour, size, position, orientation or sound alone. A screen reader user hears none of those properties, a person using magnification sees only a small part of the screen at a time, and on a phone "the right-hand column" has usually moved below the content.

The criterion does not ban such cues. W3C notes that shape and position help many users, including people with cognitive disabilities, as long as the instruction also gives another way to identify the thing, usually its visible label or heading. Where "above" and "below" mean earlier and later in the reading order, a phrase like "choose one of the links below" passes when the reference is unambiguous. Requirements about colour as such are in 1.4.1.

/ How pages fail it

  • A survey says "press the round button to submit and the square one to cancel", and both buttons show only an icon.
  • A help page says "the forms are in the right-hand column", which on a phone is rendered below the article.
  • A form says "click the green button to continue", and the button itself reads "Go".
  • A product list marks availability with a circle or a square, and the legend explains the two only by their shapes.
  • An online test says "answer when you hear the signal", and nothing on screen changes at that moment.

/ How to check it yourself

  1. Read every instruction on the page: form hints, help text, error messages, tooltips, onboarding steps and legends.
  2. Mark each one that points at something by shape, colour, size, position on screen, orientation or sound.
  3. For each marked instruction, check that the same sentence also names the thing by its visible label, heading or text.
  4. Turn on a free screen reader, NVDA on Windows or VoiceOver on a Mac or iPhone, and follow the instruction without looking.
  5. Narrow the window to phone width, or zoom to 400 percent, and check whether "left", "right" and "sidebar" still describe where things are.

/ How to fix it

  • Name the control by its label: "select Submit" instead of "select the round button". Keeping the visual hint is fine: "the green Next button at the bottom".
  • Replace references to position with the name of a heading or an in-page link: "see Related forms", linked to #related-forms.
  • Give icon-only buttons a visible text label so an instruction has a word to point to.
  • Put text next to every symbol in a legend, "In stock" and "On back order", or give the symbol images alt text that says the same.
  • Pair every sound cue with a visible change on screen and a text message, for example a status line that reads "Recording started".

/ What our scanner checks

Our scan has no check filed under 1.3.3. Finding an instruction that leans on shape, position, colour or sound means reading the copy with the layout in mind, for example spotting "the green button" and then checking whether the button is also named. A person does that reading during a manual audit.

/ Who fails it, in our own measurements

The weekly index has no figures for this criterion, because none of the checks the site scan runs can test it. A person judges it, which is what a manual audit is for.

One page per body, measured by automated checks on a weekly schedule. Any body that has fixed something since the last sweep will show it at the next one, and every entity page carries a right of reply.

/ Questions about this criterion

Is "see below" allowed under WCAG?

Yes, in most cases. W3C explains that in languages where "above" and "below" refer to what comes before and after in the content, phrases such as "choose one of the links below" or "all of the above" conform, provided the content referred to sits in that place in the reading order and the reference is unambiguous. "The box on the left" is a different matter, because left has no meaning in the reading order.

What is the difference between 1.3.3 and 1.4.1 Use of Color?

1.3.3 is about instructions: they must not rely only on sensory characteristics such as shape, colour, size, location or sound. 1.4.1 is about any information: colour must not be the only visual means of conveying it, of indicating an action or of distinguishing an element. An instruction that says only "click the green button" can fail both.

Can instructions still mention icons, colours and positions?

Yes. W3C says shape and location are an effective cue for many users, including people with cognitive disabilities, and the criterion should not discourage them. The word "solely" is the requirement. "Select the green arrow labelled Next in the lower right corner" passes, because the label is there for anyone who cannot see the arrow or its colour.